alt Hacker NewsBy that standard, we could have AGI tomorrow, and I should still not comment.
No, my app is not published yet. It will probably take another month, with hopefully no complications arising out of the AppStore review process.
Then, I hope the ad campaign financials work out to compete with old apps of a lower quality that already boast no less than a million reviews.
I get it, you want me to make a case that can objectively convince you of the usefulness of agentic development without code review.
From my perspective, I have no interest in doing so, and I can only share my experience so far. In a few months time we will know more objectively whether my ambitions paid off.
Until then, you will either have to take my word for the quality of the product, or spend tens to hundreds of hours of effort in trying the approach for yourself. OP's article does not contain any specifics for where and how supposedly agentic development failed him either.
Replies
> you will either have to take my word for the quality of the product, or spend tens to hundreds of hours of effort in trying the approach for yourself
You're acting like everyone here doesn't have hundreds of hours of experience with LLM coding. We all do, we all know what it's like.
You're simply either lying or wrong. If it's the former, I don't care, you're just an asshole on the internet. If it's the latter, you'll learn eventually and it will be quite painful for you.
But can't you see how coming out with a strong statement like "i've been doing this, it works" before your app even has a single user and before you've had to contend with any externally filed bug reports and keep the app stable as you fix those and add new features isn't very reasonable?
If anything there are clear counter example to your claim, such as the major provider agent harnesses which are all almost always fully vibe coded, and riddled with bugs and regressions that make using them painful for users. The only reason people put up with it is because competition in the space is still limited.