logoalt Hacker News

arkmmtoday at 1:37 PM4 repliesview on HN

"Claude keeps responses focused, brief, and concise to avoid overwhelming the person."

Claude and I must have a different idea of what brief and concise mean.


Replies

tgsovlerkhgseltoday at 2:38 PM

If you think Claude is bad at this, try Gemini. Even with explicit user prompts.

Claude seems to be better (not good, but significantly better) at judging where making the answer longer will actually be helpful (e.g. adding important information/context/nuance that a short answer would miss, thinking a step ahead, etc.).

treetalkertoday at 2:11 PM

The model almost certainly lacks accurate conceptions of overwhelming and person.

roncesvallestoday at 5:42 PM

Imagine what it's like without that line.