logoalt Hacker News

defrosttoday at 1:50 AM2 repliesview on HN

Not my specification (drive by third party)

but I do take the view that ( 1, 2, 3, 4, 5, 5, 6 ) is a list of seven values (perhaps the number of dollars in the pockets of seven distinct unique people) and when sorted the output should also have seven items that correspond to the seven input items.

> Also ...

Yeah, that needs tightening up by pastel8739


Replies

Jtsummerstoday at 1:56 AM

You need a way to differentiate the two 5s, that isn't present. If you had a list like:

  L = [(5,foo), (2,bar), (2,baz),...]
And did a:

  SORT(L, key=first) # or however it'd be specified
Then the duplicate 2s would be fine, because they're no longer duplicates, only duplicate keys. But it would still fail if (2,baz) showed up twice in the source and destination even though we've asked for SORT, not UNIQSORT.
show 2 replies
inigyoutoday at 2:07 AM

The specification said

    Every item in I is present exactly once in S
5 is an item in I, and it is present exactly once in S.
show 1 reply