logoalt Hacker News

shimmanyesterday at 6:16 PM2 repliesview on HN

Having people personally go out of the way for a little bit of friction tells you how valuable, and perhaps, serious these people are. I'd rather have that group of people contributing to my projects than fly by night agents that just shit all over the floor and expect treats for doing so.


Replies

ygjbyesterday at 6:36 PM

Contributions aren't just commits/prs. It's also opening issues. The harder it is to provide feedback, the more likely users are going to seek a different library or tool, and depending on the actual objective of releasing or publishing code, that is not ideal.

I do agree on the fly by night agents, especially since so much is actually just agents acting on behalf of folks who just spam whatever permissions are requested in Claude/Codex.

show 1 reply
lawnyesterday at 7:09 PM

It's also a useful signal in the age of LLMs. A bit of hoops to jump through before a PR can now be seen as a good thing.