logoalt Hacker News

ggmyesterday at 11:00 PM1 replyview on HN

love the use of "solid" when both numbers (50, and the other 50) are pure unobtanium pulled out of an orifice.

"a lot" would be less rhetorically satisfying, but probably more appropriate.

I suspect the number is in fact, far less than 50%. In mining engineering, I'd be amazed if a significant majority of the rules don't stem from a significant accident or death, or forseeable need to avoid them. In medicine, the stakes are equally high. Building codes? It depends. The cost of tunnelling in NY isn't because of government compliance.


Replies

knollimartoday at 10:44 AM

In building codes, sometimes there's a tragedy that causes government overreach. A death with big public support often causes regulation that "does something" even if the rule itself doesn't help or make sense.