logoalt Hacker News

readthenotes1yesterday at 8:43 PM3 repliesview on HN

Doesn't civilization just literally mean a system of living together in a city? There doesn't need to be any written record of how they did it does there, just evidence that they did?


Replies

andsoitistoday at 12:40 PM

> Doesn't civilization just literally mean a system of living together in a city?

The classic checklist definition is: cities, writing, centralized state, agriculture, social stratification with rulers.

show 1 reply
xhevahiryesterday at 9:24 PM

What counts as a city? Anyway, we're talking about a concept involving family resemblances rather than an airtight set of sufficient-and-necessary conditions.

mc32yesterday at 8:47 PM

Urbanization is one qualifier but not the only one. Plus even today we could have such chaos in a town where laws are absent and justice is that dispensed by the strongman/woman warlord and that would hardly be considered civilization.

Uncivilized does not mean stupid or brutes.

show 2 replies