logoalt Hacker News

qurrenyesterday at 10:18 PM3 repliesview on HN

> Quebec Maple Syrup Producers organization

Can you just not join the organization?

Maple trees are living things and have a right to reproduce, you can't fault a bird for shitting maple seeds all over my farm planting maple trees everywhere.


Replies

autoexectoday at 4:16 AM

It looks like you're forced to participate by law once you sell over a certain volume.

> Backed by the Canadian civil courts, the federation has the monopoly for selling Quebecois maple syrup on the wholesale market, and for exporting it outside the province. Producers are only allowed to sell independently cans of less than five litres or 5kg to visitors to their farm. https://www.bbc.com/news/business-35028380

scorpioxytoday at 12:00 AM

I saw a documentary(forgot the name, sorry) about that that said, no you can't choose not to join. I forgot if it was about this organization but it was about maple production in Canada where a farmer wanted to do their own thing and they were intimidated and all sorts of nasty things happen to them because they didn't think the org was just and wanted to sell freely. Very interesting documentary and an eye opener that even farmer unions can act like organized crime when there's money involved.

baby_souffletoday at 12:03 AM

> you can't fault a bird for shitting maple seeds all over my farm planting maple trees everywhere.

If only building a ram FAB was that easy :).

The best hope is that cxmt gets going quicker than expected and is able to satisfy a decent chunk of the Chinese demand for RAM which would - in theory - reduce the demand for ram from the few other producers.