logoalt Hacker News

Sha1rholdertoday at 5:17 AM5 repliesview on HN

Why would they cut corners? Activated carbon isn’t expensive.


Replies

Retrictoday at 5:53 AM

Because it’s not obvious to most customers that a corner’s been cut. Same reason most new construction in the US sucks.

You can safely put a washer and dryer on the upper floor of a house if you add a proper floor drain, but you’re unlikely to see anyone add a floor drain in new construction because buyers aren’t looking for it. Now multiply that by everything a buyer isn’t looking for and you’re talking real money.

show 2 replies
victorbjorklundtoday at 9:20 AM

You have companies choosing the component that cost 10 cents instead of 15 cents even if the 10 cents component will break 10 times faster than the more expensive one.

Aurornistoday at 6:07 AM

You simply cannot put enough activated carbon in a little foam thing that goes in front of a filter to do anything useful.

The real activated carbon filters have 10s of pounds of carbon. The little black foam thing that comes with those 2-in-1 carbon filters is useless.

show 1 reply
karlgkktoday at 5:48 AM

But it does cost money and so… corners are cut

gib444today at 7:22 AM

The clue is in your name