logoalt Hacker News

rexpopyesterday at 10:25 PM6 repliesview on HN

The rights delineated in the American Constitution are understood to precede the government being held to account for them. Furthermore, they are held to be universal, natural rights.


Replies

wimltoday at 6:18 AM

I think you're getting the Declaration and the Constitution a little mixed up. Also conflating "free speech" with "the first amendment", but everyone does that so they can motte-and-bailey.

ydattoday at 12:58 PM

> Furthermore, they are held to be universal, natural rights.

Schizophrenic nonsense. If said rights are inalienable, why do you need them to be protected. I could shoot you and “alienate” several of those rights with no effort whatsoever.

chabskatoday at 2:28 AM

You would think that the right to bear arms would extend to Iran developing a nuclear warhead though.

show 1 reply
dghftoday at 8:26 AM

The right to a trial by jury in civil suits where the sum in dispute is greater than US$20 is a universal natural right?

tomlockwoodyesterday at 10:57 PM

Says who?

gambitingyesterday at 10:57 PM

...is that what Americans believe?