logoalt Hacker News

frollogastontoday at 4:22 AM2 repliesview on HN

Texting is the single most important feature on a phone.

Also it's not Apple's fault that MMS was terrible for years and now RCS is still terrible. Google also tried to make their own proprietary chat and failed... like 10 times. But more importantly, I don't care, this is not my battle. I'd use WhatsApp if that's what people did here, not that I like it any better.


Replies

TheDongtoday at 5:14 AM

Yes it is Apple's fault.

The iMessage app does both SMS, and the iMessage protocol. Apple could have released an android app to let you have blue bubbles on android and communicate securely without any of the constraints of SMS by simply releasing "iMessage for Android".

Somehow Signal, Whatsapp, Telegram, Discord, WeChat, LINE, KakaoTalk, etc etc all manage to have both iOS and Android apps that can message each other, but for some reason the richest company in the world, Apple, cannot manage to port its chat app to one additional platform?

It is 100% Apple's fault that messaging between iOS and Android has had so much dumb "green bubble" friction.

Apple's conflation of the SMS and iMessage protocols has also made it harder for people to realize what's happening. Frankly, Apple should have had two apps from the start (Text Message and iMessage), one of which only spoke SMS, and the other of which only spoke iMessage.

show 1 reply
shaklee3today at 4:38 AM

RCS is not terrible. Apple's implementation of RCS is terrible.

show 1 reply