logoalt Hacker News

kstenerudtoday at 6:20 PM2 repliesview on HN

When you look at their live demo (https://shieldfont.org/demo/), it says: If you use a screen reader, custom font, or translator, please uncover the text before reading.

They also actively block copying the text, telling you to "uncover" the text first. The uncover operation is VERY expensive.

Anyone using assistive technologies or trying to copy "protected" text is SOL.

Search engines will index the decoy. You'll get no traffic. Their solution is basically putting yourself in a black hole.


Replies

317070today at 9:46 PM

> Search engines will index the decoy. You'll get no traffic. Their solution is basically putting yourself in a black hole.

It's only search engines? And who uses those anymore anyway? Other bots?

It doesn't affect organic traffic, so you are not really putting yourself into a black hole. A lot of website are driven by social media and organic traffic, so they would be just fine with this approach.

evnptoday at 6:54 PM

Isn't this the same sort of cost CloudFlare and anime catgirls are making us pay daily? Only enough to deter bots, or "a few seconds processing."

I take your point that one extra click/interaction required for screen readers only is objectively more friction, but it's only by exploring these technologies instead of dismissing them that we'll arrive at UX solutions truly work for people of all stripes (and ideally, not for bots, scrapers, and the like). I think if you're applying a tool like this you already have very different priorities than fueling Google.

show 1 reply