logoalt Hacker News

Maxatartoday at 3:44 PM1 replyview on HN

Compacting mostly gets rid of reasoning tokens, and honestly it would be nice of reasoning tokens did not constantly follow every follow up query. Asking even a simple/trivial question can have Claude use thousands of tokens. Compacting is good for getting rid of those.


Replies

troupotoday at 4:35 PM

I've had Claude immediately fall back to its usual verbose style immediately after compaction.

To be fair, I've had it do that immediately after re-reading the output style instructions, too.

My chat history is filled with "Yes, I broke the language rule. Let me rephrase that and update my memory. — You already have that in memory — Yes, true, I ignored that" (because "Memory" is a yet another .md file)

show 1 reply