logoalt Hacker News

groby_btoday at 8:28 PM1 replyview on HN

4A still doesn't permit you to destroy the evidence. Resist on 4A grounds, destroy the evidence, 4A reasons get overturned - you've got yourself a conviction. US v. Akram Musleh.


Replies

insane_dreamertoday at 9:39 PM

in practice you're right, but it's hard to see how that squares with the 4A.

an officer can't stop me on the street and demand to see the contents of my phone -- unless they can show "probable cause" that I was about to commit a crime (based on other evidence), or I'm already named as a suspect or POI in an investigation. So if they ask to see the contents of my phone and I delete it instead (it's a very small bag in this example, Lol) am I obstructing an investigation?

show 1 reply