logoalt Hacker News

Vegenoidyesterday at 9:13 PM1 replyview on HN

Agree with the thrust of your comment, but I had to comment on this:

> In a full banana republic, technical compliance with the law will not prevent consequences for failing to do what the authorities want. In a jurisdiction with perfect rule of law, it always will.

I think you may be misunderstanding that many laws, even in fair, just societies, are intentionally designed to be flexible. The real world is so variable and messy that in many cases it isn't feasible for a law to be written such it can be unambiguously determined whether or not a specific action violated the law. Laws often rely on humans using context to judge whether something violates the spirit of a law, and in a just society, this is a good thing.

My point is that I don't believe the idea of "perfect rule of law" is sensible. Law is always necessarily a bit fuzzy and nebulous.


Replies

malfistyesterday at 11:08 PM

Theres a reason why the motto of banana republic leaders is: "For my friends, everything. For my enemies, the law"