alt Hacker News> To get a good terminal UX, I think the answer to this is probably to throw all that compatibility mess away and redesign a modern terminal protocol that bakes in accessibility, regions, scrolling, selection, proper keyboard, etc.
Why not just… a GUI framework or layout that’s meant to be keyboard driven and information dense?
Replies
It’s trivially easy to run a TUI in a container. Not so much with GUIs. And, since I run as much as possible in containers, and as little as possible on my host machine, I much prefer TUIs.
there's a million gui frameworks under the sun and i still haven't found one that feels like what everyone has been asking for:
good dx, cross platform, fast, not ugly.
pick i dunno 2 or 3.
tui's get to check 2 or 3 of these just like any other gui library. somehow there still isn't a silver bullet here.
now i personally don't build tuis but guake style dropdown simple command and i have some other thing someone made open immediately running in ghostty? hell yea. with that said yes there are some stupid tuis out there that are anything but simple.
Agreed. This is exactly what I want, ideally with components and libraries and panels and data shareable and extendable between applications.
The closest in spirit is Probably something like Dear ImGui[0] and the ecosystem of components and apps built with it, but it's not quite there for me. Something is missing.
charm.sh builds many such things. I love them and their personality.
Countless reasons.
Invent a gui client environment that is universal, works the same way everywhere, over any kind of channel, and is already implimented and supported everywhere, and utterly weightless in all dimensions (ram/cpu/network), and then you might be able to ask that question without it being incredibly ignorant.
Today the closest you might be able to say is web/electron, which is gross on all counts. If anything the closest is X11, which is not remotely close enough.
That's why not just...
TUIs run on any OS with minor patches to support quirks, GUI frameworks need a lot of work. TUIs don't need to follow any OS guidelines, cross-platform GUIs always look bad outside of the "main" platform.
If you're only targeting macOS/Windows/Gnome/KDE then the solution is easy: just grab a GUI control set and go ham.
Then there's remote access: you can spawn an X11 app through X forwarding and have a terrible laggy experience on Linux, you can use RemoteApps on Windows to have a good remote experience (but almost no other platform), you can use VNC to have an awful cross-platform experience, or you can use a TUI and have all the graphs and interactivity you need over a responsive, low-bandwidth connection on any combination of client+server.