logoalt Hacker News

bdhdhduuydtoday at 7:27 AM3 repliesview on HN

For me the comparison has always been 3DsMax vs Blender. Same kind of software, same kind of features, but Blender is so much faster.

Architectural decisions have always been important.


Replies

MaxL93today at 9:53 AM

You could compare it to Windows vs. Linux in a sense. 3ds Max has decades of legacy plugin/SDK compatibility baggage, lots of commercial and contractual obligations with business/enterprise customers... and Blender has none of those things weighing it down.

show 1 reply
inigyoutoday at 1:19 PM

Fun blender fact: every .blend file contains a serialisation of the complete data model of the blender version that wrote it. That's why they have a minimum file size of about 280kB.

moffkalasttoday at 7:39 AM

Ha, I'm always struggling with UI performance in Blender. Undo takes ages and freezes up everything, modifiers start lagging mouse movement as soon as you have more than a handful of polygons. I shudder to imagine what Max must be like.

Though I must admit you can have an absolute shit ton of ridiculously complex objects in a scene, and it will run smoothly if none of them is in edit mode which is at least fairly impressive.