logoalt Hacker News

ninjagootoday at 5:29 PM14 repliesview on HN

So no merit, effort or capability-based gains; instead a straight title, prestige, wealth and inheritance gain through DNA, over which no offspring has any control.


Replies

tecleandortoday at 6:47 PM

He got equal inheritance rights as every person gets from his parents. In this case I see it as "You had a kid, you better take charge of that."

Also:

> But he will not receive a royal allowance, nor will he be expected to take on official duties, and he has no rights to the Belgian throne. Vandenkerckhove could take his father’s family name, Saxe-Coburg, but has indicated he may not choose to.

show 1 reply
vltoday at 6:51 PM

” But he will not receive a royal allowance, nor will he be expected to take on official duties, and he has no rights to the Belgian throne.”

So it seems nothing will change for him.

show 2 replies
green_wheeltoday at 7:17 PM

Yeah, people leave their things to their children. It's been happening for quite some time now. You should look into it.

afpxtoday at 8:13 PM

Wait, you mean there's a place in the world where people with merit, effort, and capability thrive?

show 1 reply
geremiiahtoday at 8:58 PM

His ancestors murdered and stole a whole lot for him to gain that priviledge.

dgellowtoday at 9:09 PM

That’s what royalty is

mrtksntoday at 9:29 PM

Sounds like any rich kid ever TBH.

michaeljxtoday at 5:31 PM

Like the good nepotistic society we are

show 1 reply
terabytesttoday at 6:58 PM

Sounds like the definition of monarchy?

ck2today at 9:37 PM

could be worse, there are people all over the world that look startling a lot like Musk including in Africa but he won't do DNA tests

(not making this up, google it)

toomuchtodotoday at 9:59 PM

This is reality, meritocracy is the exception, not the rule.

skrebbeltoday at 5:41 PM

Wealth gain? How?

show 1 reply
bell-cottoday at 5:49 PM

Are you advocating for all children being anonymized and raised in orphanages? Or a 100% inheritance tax? Or just expressing disappointment at your own relative lack of wealthy & famous recent ancestors?

show 1 reply
zuzululutoday at 6:58 PM

If you view this life as a simulation and that this is the only possible one you will inhibit, it all looks absurd for the very thing you mentioned, the snapshot of it alone suggests chaos stochastic properties with seemingly no order but this isn't your fault as much of Western perspective has judeo-christian roots reject the Eastern philosophy that have preceded it for several milllenias thus I'd argue would be more grounded and accurate seeing that geographically isolated and separated cultures who have never come into contact with other have discovered the same conclusions.

The new wave movement in the West frame it as a simulation hypothesis perspective, your DNA is the passport through many simulations you've experienced and it carries the merit, effort and capabilities gained over time.

We just call it Buddhism outside san francisco.