logoalt Hacker News

I Dream of Quieter Computing

106 pointsby Sir_Twisttoday at 2:33 AM108 commentsview on HN

Comments

mrobtoday at 8:17 AM

>Everything these days is glass and refresh rates

The higher the display refresh rate the metaphorically "quieter" the computer. Discrete frames introduce latency, phantom array effect, and (on most displays) sample-and-hold blur. These don't exist in real life, so they weaken the illusion of the computer becoming part of your body, like a pencil or a hand tool. A computer that can be operated with minimum cognitive load needs a display refresh rate of at least 1000 Hz.

show 3 replies
andaitoday at 5:13 AM

I tried clicking the "#551A8B streaks" link, looking forward to reading a rant about websites overriding link color (and link underlines to boot!)

But I was bamboozled! The link wasn't a link. It was just colored text! My disappointment is immeasurable, and my day is ruined.

That said, this is a very cool website.

tietjenstoday at 5:41 AM

I expected this to be literally about quieter computers.

show 1 reply
bibabalootoday at 5:13 AM

There's precedent here in things like fast food vs. farm to table, mass produced goods vs arts and craft, digital photography vs film. Yet at least in my social circle, I don't really hear anyone pining for an 'artisan internet'. Maybe it's because the internet is seen more as a tool than something to experience. Or maybe it's because we're still early in the 'mass produced internet' age. Or maybe network effects make transitioning away from the big networks to smaller ones difficult, unless you're only communicating with online-first groups. It'll be interesting to see what happens in the future, because right now it certainly seems like things are trending in the opposite direction.

show 2 replies
VCFundedGenYertoday at 4:12 PM

>Everything these days is glass and refresh rates

As it was in the 70s, 80s, and 90s all the same. I don't understand what this article is talking about.

jtrntoday at 8:32 AM

What a wholsome and inclusive site. Page title reads “fix your heart or die”. Spread the love indeed.

show 3 replies
mmackhtoday at 5:06 AM

A lot of folks will tell you that computers with less features are the the answer, but over the past couple of years I’ve come to realise that how we interact (keyboard and mouse) with computers now is only one way to do it.

There’s something about building distraction-free computing, that doesn’t have to be less. I’ve been building something over the past five years, that puts an entire smart home into one device - sensors and microcontrollers have come incredibly far to make it feel a little bit like magic. What I’m getting at is - what if the environment provides input to the computer and not us directly? This would be one way of exploring quieter computing.

show 1 reply
rao-vtoday at 4:54 AM

Esp32s with eink displays are pretty much this

never_inlinetoday at 5:39 PM

Five paragraphs of saying almost nothing.

lproventoday at 9:49 AM

From a few months ago and highly relevant:

https://ratfactor.com/ascetic-computing

show 1 reply
frgturpwdtoday at 11:20 AM

weird hill(s) to die on

ktalletttoday at 6:21 AM

Often we are missing something in that we don't need to change what we use quite so regularly. We can learn to enjoy tech of the past and still find it useful today. It would both be better for the planet and satisfy our realisation that constant upgrades and changes aren't always needed or even better.

Does a Canon S90 suddenly take bad photos or take photos that can't be printed? No, of course not, and that's a decade old.

Can you still write on a Thinkpad X201? Yes of course. If anything, that keyboard is far better.

znpytoday at 12:57 PM

> of handmade websites viewed on hackable hardware

but what if I don't what to hack my hardware? what if instead for me my hardware is just a tool i use from time to time to open my banking stuff, send/receive email to keep in touch with friends, watch movies and in my spare time i do other stuff?

what if instead of hacking my hardware i want to go swimming, or take care of my garden, or cook or play the piano?

articles like this make me chuckle nowadays because we in the tech industry assume most people are like us. they aren't. for them computers are just a tool. the less they get nagged by their tools, the better.

unironically, that's why apple has so much success. apple's hardware is as far as you can get from hackability. they fix in place a lot of degrees of freedom (both in hardware and in software) and in exchange you get tools that work very well and very reliably.

the author of this post should really touch grass more often.

(i know i'll be downvoted for writing this, i don't care).

userbinatortoday at 6:19 AM

..and I dream of less activist sites.

show 1 reply