logoalt Hacker News

sreanyesterday at 10:02 AM4 repliesview on HN

But nowhere close to the emotional impact.

People usually do not remember what happened turn by turn but they do remember what it made them feel.

Funnily enough, in the movie, the humans have little no feelings but the androids do -- and that is the central question that the movie made me consider -- what makes us human.

I am ofcourse biased because Blade Runner (original) is not only on my top 5 scifi movie list but also on my top 5 movie list. So much so that I am reluctant to watch 2049.


Replies

bwilli123yesterday at 4:02 PM

I most liked that just before his death Roy crafted some poetry. Creating Art? Isn't that what it means to be human?

show 1 reply
stuartdyesterday at 12:18 PM

> But nowhere close to the emotional impact

It may be trite but “Because if a machine, a Terminator, can learn the value of human life, maybe we can, too.” gets me every single time

TheOtherHobbesyesterday at 10:29 AM

I think Blade Runner and Alien helped destroy mainstream science fiction.

Before Blade Runner almost anything could be science fiction. After Blade Runner science fiction meant detective noir with #tech_upgrade - clones, memory implants, dystopia. Or it was US truckers and/or the military fighting nasty aliens in spaaaaaaace. (Star Wars and its magic space knights was always more fantasy with a science fiction stage set.)

Blade Runner did it far better than the others, but then we had decades of mostly mediocre book knock-offs, especially in the UK. (Gibson gets a pass for taking the new trope even further by being a brilliant stylist, mixing in some tech orientalism, and inventing cyberspace.)

It's a stunning, iconic masterpiece of a movie with an unfortunate chilling cultural effect.

And ironically the Philip K Dick original was... very different.

show 4 replies