logoalt Hacker News

cogman10today at 7:03 PM2 repliesview on HN

One definition of a cult I've liked is "A cult is a group you can't leave with your dignity intact". You can really get a good understanding if something is a cult by the way they talk about their ex members. A healthy organization will pretty much just say "Sad to see you go, come back anytime". Unhealthy organizations spend a fair amount of time warning members about how how dangerous/bad/sinful/sad/miserable their ex members are.

And yes, I'd call several mainstream religions cults because of this. I'd not argue that something isn't a cult if they don't fit this definition, but a very large number of the most damaging cults do have this behavior.


Replies

graemeptoday at 7:11 PM

> And yes, I'd call several mainstream religions cults because of this

Which ones ? Not something I have seen myself

I do like your definition. Its a pretty clear and meaningful distinction and linked to other cult behaviours such as encouraging members to cease contact with ex-members.

show 1 reply
jcsagertoday at 7:54 PM

Apostasy is treated very severely by many (most?) religions. The cults have just borrowed that concept.

show 1 reply