logoalt Hacker News

FDA clears blood test to aid evaluation for Alzheimer's disease

174 pointsby dabinattoday at 6:30 AM87 commentsview on HN

Comments

brandonbtoday at 7:40 AM

This Alzheimer's blood test, PrecivityAD2, is based on the p-tau217 biomarker.

In one recent study, people very high p-tau217 had a 38% chance of progressing to cognitive impairment within 5 years vs 12% for those with low levels. The current tests cost about $200-300, so they're not unreasonable as a screening test. PrecivityAD2 looks to be priced around $1,400-$1,500 so at that price, this specific test likely only makes sense for people with established disease.

show 6 replies
debo_today at 9:25 PM

I work directly in this field (clinically validated digital cognitive tests that characterize cognition, often paired with p-tau blood tests.) Ask me anything, I guess!

show 1 reply
ggmtoday at 8:14 AM

Do we yet have any good avoidance or mitigation regimes, be they drug or otherwise for people who show positive on a test like this? The alternative is that it lets you put things in place for when you lose agency.

Good as in scientifically proven. Not speculative fantasy.

show 5 replies
Pawenniagtoday at 12:06 PM

If this gets cheap enough and the predictive values hold up in ordinary clinical populations, it could change when people actually get evaluated rather than just how they get evaluated

show 1 reply
willmaddentoday at 1:50 PM

Why is the FDA "clearing" something that is completely innocuous like a blood test?

show 5 replies
ozereray1today at 11:46 AM

[dead]

maximgeorgetoday at 9:21 AM

[flagged]

akarshhegde18today at 8:07 AM

[dead]

hnsmomdpvptoday at 11:32 AM

[dead]

hn_submittoday at 10:20 AM

These tests are more or less useless because there's no treatment anyway so knowing about it a long time in advance will not lead to any substantial gain. Even slowing the disease isn't within the realm of today's technology. Today's pharmaceutical companies are close to quacks as far as Alzheimer is concerned. We know next to nothing about its origins or even how the disease progresses.

The only thing you gain is giving people more time to worry and despair.

show 4 replies