logoalt Hacker News

devttyeutoday at 4:16 PM8 repliesview on HN

Sad to see it go having been a maintainer some years ago.

For anyone wondering, there are more sustainable (with a viable, focused business backing the project) options to do p2p, namely Iroh - https://www.iroh.computer/ which was built by ex-IPFS ex-Protocol Labs devs (I have no relation to the team beyond having worked with them back in the day).

Sadly Protocol Labs is doing.. ehh whatever now, except apparently supporting the projects it got its VC/crypto funding from.


Replies

momack2today at 8:02 PM

Iroh is great! As is ATProto! Both build on DASL (https://dasl.ing/bdasl.html) - which specifies the core content addressing layer of IPFS.

However - important clarification about the Shipyard post that I think a lot of folks are confused by:

While its sad to see the Shipyard team sunset, the IPFS project is decentralized & robust to a single party moving on. IPFS the project/network is not sunsetting or shutting down!

Current focus is lighter-weight stewardship from the IPFS Foundation via grants to individual maintainers, & development of decentralized public infra tools like the Service Worker Gateway.

show 1 reply
tonyhbtoday at 6:10 PM

Iroh seems more comparable to an L7 scoped Tailscale than it does IPFS. It's good, but pretty unrelated.

show 2 replies
erlend_shtoday at 7:21 PM

Perhaps the best thing to have come out of IPFS is DASL, used in AT protocol: https://dasl.ing/

show 1 reply
dgellowtoday at 4:55 PM

What is PL doing nowadays? I checked the website and don’t understand at all

show 6 replies
CommanderDatatoday at 4:32 PM

I love Iroh but it doesn't quite work the same as IPFS if I understand correctly.

show 2 replies
jadboxtoday at 5:38 PM

who uses Iroh?

show 4 replies
doctorpanglosstoday at 6:32 PM

there are a lot of completely free file sharing services for authentic activity (e.g. github, google drive)

inauthentic activity seems to move from one product space to another. in 3 years we'll be hearing about stripe shutting down openrouter for example.

show 1 reply