logoalt Hacker News

Commercially Available Bike Generators Are Not Sustainable (2011)

40 pointsby baud147258last Wednesday at 3:04 PM33 commentsview on HN

Comments

erelongtoday at 1:18 AM

Might have changed their attitude since then as they posted in 2022 about a DIY guide on making a bike generator: https://solar.lowtechmagazine.com/2022/03/how-to-build-a-pra...

show 2 replies
usrusryesterday at 11:01 PM

Needs "2011" in the title. For example the section about friction drive hasn't been true for about a decade now

show 2 replies
rgmerktoday at 12:40 AM

This arguably had some relevance in 2011. In 2026, cheap solar and batteries make human-powered static devices that would benefit from the extra power of a stationary cyclist completely redundant.

tocs3last Wednesday at 3:49 PM

Some things I would like to see are pedal controlled devices. Something like a pedal controlled wheelchair, not powered by the pedals just control the forward and back motion. My mother with sever arthritis can still pedal but has a very hard time walking. It would be a little exercise doing something that needs to be done (getting around). A pedal controlled remote control lawnmower would be nifty also.

show 3 replies
Mugshelftoday at 12:11 AM

Tried one at a demo; you put in a ton of work for minimal wattage. Much better off with a decent power bank, honestly.

mmoosstoday at 4:50 AM

> An energy loss of 42 to 67.5 percent of naturally means that it takes 42 to 67.5 percent more effort or time to power a device (say, a blender) via electricity compared to powering the same device mechanically.

Nope. If input is 100W, loss is 60%, and resulting in output of 40W, then to increase output to 100W you don't need 60% more input (which would output 64W) you need 150% more input.

scotty79yesterday at 11:16 PM

You could attach pedals directly to motor axle and control charging power drawn precisely to ensure smooth rotation in absence of the flywheel. It could be really small.

show 1 reply
xyzsparetimexyztoday at 1:08 AM

So Black Mirror lied to me ?!

486sx33yesterday at 11:17 PM

[dead]

kelvo_ranyesterday at 11:56 PM

[dead]