logoalt Hacker News

lukanyesterday at 7:44 PM1 replyview on HN

And then you'd still have to ask yourself, whether anything is real or a simulation, or a dream of god, etc.

Otherwise history is indeed much guesswork, as we don't have a timemachine and rely on lot's of indirect evidence for everything.


Replies

MomsAVoxellyesterday at 11:50 PM

This is like looking at a seismograph or an electrocardiogram and concluding that it doesn’t represent anything worth knowing “because nothing is real”, “they were just dreaming because they were primitive”, or “we don’t have a <mythological and impossible device> to prove these stories”.

We do have methods of proving these stories - we can dig trenches and see the history as it was described, in the land itself.

Please, do not dismiss this on the basis of some authoritarian postulates about not having developed your own cultures time machines. Song lines literally are a verifiable time record.

show 1 reply