logoalt Hacker News

ErroneousBoshyesterday at 9:45 PM2 repliesview on HN

There is absolutely no reason for any sane video editing software to be able to read VFR files.

It should, however, reject them gracefully but positively.


Replies

account42today at 8:54 AM

Of course there is. A lot of older TV shows are effectively variable frame rates when properly detelecined/deinterlaced. And mixing two fixed frame rate sources with different framerates would naturally produce a VFR video and with current editing software you need to destroy some of the source information or interpolate some slop to make it work. There is no good reason for editing software to have these limitations either when most players and all modern video containers have caught up and are VFR-first with a fixed frame rate hint in the headers if you're lucky.

nosrepayesterday at 11:35 PM

I read that last bit in Hank Hill's voice.