logoalt Hacker News

chickenbigyesterday at 8:00 PM1 replyview on HN

> There is no way SMR could beat solar+battery power cost even now.

Not a particular fan of this paper, but it does illustrate a point ... https://ieeexplore.ieee.org/document/8867359 showed that for the UK to go 100% solar it would need an energy capacity of 1/3 of the total grid energy demand over the year. Figure 6 A shows the big trend of 6 1/2 months of discharge and 5 1/2 months of charge (i.e. cycle perhaps once a year). Seasonal variations do matter.


Replies

ViewTrick1002yesterday at 8:30 PM

Not sure what relevancy a 2019 paper has today?

It also seems like they are constraining the system to have no overproduction.

It’s like assuming that a fossil based system has all its producers generating the expected capacity factor and then smoothing out the season and daily demand changes with storage. Due to the difference between summer and winter demand such a fossil system would also need to have months of storage to compensate.

Which of course is absolute stupidity. When you can just overbuild production capacity and leave a far simpler problem to solve.