logoalt Hacker News

hn_throwaway_99today at 2:19 AM1 replyview on HN

> In conclusion, I’m pretty negative about AI in general, but this experience made me cautiously optimistic about the role the technology could play in protecting consumers from counterfeit products.

Whaaaattt? How could the author go through such detail and discover that Gemini completely failed in the assigned task (calling all the products fakes when some were and some weren't means that it provided zero correct assistance in this discrimination task) and then conclude "AI could play a helpful role"??? Does the author also conclude that stopped clocks could play a helpful role telling time because the are correct twice a day?

Apparently AI isn't the only thing that hallucinates.


Replies

Terr_today at 4:48 AM

Perhaps a softer critique would be that the author seems to assume that (A) feature-detection will map to (B) accurate and useful conclusions, and that isn't necessarily true.