logoalt Hacker News

Defrag98: Windows 98 Disk Defragmenter Simulator Online

108 pointsby throw0101ayesterday at 10:51 PM64 commentsview on HN

Comments

vunderbayesterday at 11:53 PM

When I was younger, my friends and I joked about making a "Disk Fragmenter" which would enumerate through every file on the disk and split them into non-contiguous clusters to make sure that the actuator arm on your platter-drive gets a PROPER WORKOUT TO FEEL THE BURN.

show 2 replies
stoatstudiostoday at 1:05 AM

Perhaps it's appropriate for me to link to the free game I made where you play a taxi driving through Disk Defragmenter and delivering stray blocks of data to their final locations: https://safetystoatstudios.itch.io/ddr. It was pretty fun to watch Defragmenter as a kid, but it would have been better if it was interactive, kind of like the 3D maze screensaver.

show 1 reply
singiamtelyesterday at 11:24 PM

There's something satisfying about defragging that has been lost to time. Like oiling a squeaky engine

show 3 replies
vessenesyesterday at 11:07 PM

I love this. I wanted the disk noise, and I got it. I will say that’s a lot faster than my drives were in the late 1990s though.

show 1 reply
cosmic_cheesetoday at 12:20 AM

I recall there being some techno-mysticism surrounding defragging regarding how often and when it was necessary, what it did and didn’t help, etc. I also remember the claim “Macs don’t need defragging” but I don’t know if HFS(+) was actually any less prone to fragmentation than FAT32 was. Companies like Symantec were happy to sell defragging tools to Mac users regardless.

show 1 reply
Hobadeeyesterday at 11:31 PM

I love it. A couple notes: - This is about 10x a real defrag speed - WAAAY too fast - IIRC the "Data that will not be moved" was typically lumped at the beginning of the drive, not spread out all over.

show 4 replies
pjotyesterday at 11:36 PM

Will need to degauss after this

show 1 reply
roger_yesterday at 11:09 PM

My computer's definitely gonna be faster after this.

show 1 reply
kstrausertoday at 2:35 AM

I love this. However, Amiga’s Reorg program had a vastly better display, with a larger, resizable window and individual pixels instead of large boxes. You could see much more of the disk at once and get a feel for what the entire operation was doing. Large holes would appear in the middle of a hunk of data, then large files would get moved into the hole, leaving new holes where their incontiguous blocks use to be. Defrag was nice. Reorg was captivating. I miss it.

toast0yesterday at 11:13 PM

Love the warning for using on a mobile device.

dmitrygrtoday at 4:47 AM

This seems....wrong? In the start it is writing over data in the start of the disk that has not been read/relocated (some non-free sectors NEVER light up as "Read", only as "writen") which would cause their data to be lost.

comradesmithtoday at 2:21 AM

I started the defrag on F and got about 1/4 the way, but had to stop cause my brother wanted to use the family computer.

When I changed it between drives and back I lost my progress :/

alberthtoday at 3:28 AM

Maybe my memory is bad, but I recall defrag taking hours to complete.

asmodeuslucifertoday at 2:24 AM

I used to watch defrag (and defraggler). If you have OCD they are very satisfying to watch. The more fragmented they were to start with, the better.

michaelmuretoday at 1:04 AM

In the same vein, but showing live the go allocator and GC operating on the heap of a running program: https://github.com/MichaelMure/gogc98

rbanffytoday at 3:38 AM

I wish ext4, BtrFS, and XFS had something like this.

show 1 reply
stuaxotoday at 12:20 AM

It feels a little too defragmented to start.

Typically it would be getting some bits from other parts of the drive and there would be a few (that many) bits it wouldn't move because they were the swap file and DOS boot system files.

pyaambyesterday at 11:07 PM

Need this but for AI models. Sleep mode where they self prune and optimize overnight for their daily purpose.

show 1 reply
3eb7988a1663today at 12:07 AM

There is even a click noise when you idly tap the screen.

As great as it is, way too fast.

RetroTechietoday at 12:00 AM

4 Drives, 5.5G total. Luxury!

Per-drive individual sounds, and BSoD included. Nice touches, love it!

MarvinYorkyesterday at 11:18 PM

The sound killed me... :D

chasiltoday at 12:26 AM

Defragmenting XFS is much less dramatic.

stavrosyesterday at 11:50 PM

I need to set up a Windows 95 computer with a hard drive and stream the defragging online, complete with live audio.

brcmthrowawayyesterday at 11:44 PM

What were the major filesystem technology improvements that made this redundant?

show 2 replies
wild_pointeryesterday at 11:09 PM

Legend

pir8life4meyesterday at 11:02 PM

Brilliant. Whirring disk noise is nice touch.

If AI generated this is what the AI revolution is all about.

Can we get a cross platform screensaver?

josefrichteryesterday at 11:53 PM

bill gates, I want my time back!

retiredtoday at 12:23 AM

This scratched an itch for me.

I’m going to watch Johnny Castaway now.

delducatoday at 12:17 AM

My YouTube

olivierestsageyesterday at 11:26 PM

Hot