logoalt Hacker News

drfloyd51yesterday at 10:41 PM2 repliesview on HN

One could use his flip flop to invalidate his new position. But one of those two positions is true. And if they guy who spent the most energy on position 1 changes his mind, that is worth paying attention to. His second position is likely a more informed, and true, position.


Replies

jc2jcyesterday at 11:38 PM

I don’t see why one of these two positions must be true. And just because he spent a lot of energy trying to convince others of his obsession doesn’t really convince me he has greater insight the future or how the complex consequences unfold.

qlteyesterday at 11:10 PM

That's totally true, I have no issues with a changing opinion over time. The problem is expressing both opinions with 100% certainty and not updating priors to consider that your new position could also be completely wrong.

show 1 reply