logoalt Hacker News

engine_ytoday at 5:17 AM3 repliesview on HN

Over engineering is subjective / evolving.

You could have bought a bell...


Replies

selcukatoday at 5:31 AM

> You could have bought a bell...

Over engineering is about the solution, not the requirement:

> I wanted something that lets me play a custom bell

mrbtoday at 5:28 AM

"You could have bought a bell.."

No because similar commercial products were either out of stock or not compatible with my AC voltage.

atoavtoday at 5:53 AM

If you find one that meets your requirements that is an option.

Granted maybe your requirements are ridiculous. But I also had cases where I DIYed a solution because the commercially available solutions all either didn't fulfil the requirements and/or had anti-features that ruled out their use. I haven't had any regret so far with these solutions, with some of these being active for over a decade.

There may be over engineering, but replacing a bought solution that needs to connect to the internet and someone else's computer to ring a bell with a simple 433MHz sender and a MP4-player module isn't that. Do you know what is required for a device to even connect to a WiFi? That alone is more complex than the whole system the user built here.

show 1 reply