logoalt Hacker News

odyssey7yesterday at 7:45 PM1 replyview on HN

This would be a really good discussion topic in schools.

People need to understand the dynamic between science and society, because that is an important part of how the world works today.

Pluto is an exemplar.

And also, the value of culture. It might not be a scientific result, but it still shapes our experience of the world. Pluto is beloved.


Replies

autoexecyesterday at 10:06 PM

Pluto makes for a great lesson about science itself. Our view of the universe we live in changes over time as we get more information about it. Children should learn to expect that and to understand that it isn't a bad thing, or a flaw with science, but a vital part of the process and when it happens things are working as intended. That means that today Pluto isn't a planet, even though for a small time it used to be considered one, because we learned more about the bodies in our solar system and it no longer made sense to call Pluto a planet. We can explain to children why it shows up in our history, and how we've moved on.

It honestly doesn't have to be a bunch of drama. The problem will pretty much go away after the current generation who grew up learning about Pluto as a planet dies off and gets replaced by a generation who always knew that there were only 8 planets in our solar system. Hopefully they'll also be better prepared to accept changes that come from better understanding.

show 3 replies