logoalt Hacker News

bryanlarsenyesterday at 9:21 PM2 repliesview on HN

Few things sound more like more science than "planets". Telling people "Well actually 'planet' isn't a scientific term, it's a historical / cultural term" will also significantly reduce their trust and interest in science.


Replies

xigoitoday at 8:33 AM

This is similar to how most people would say that mathematics is about numbers, but the word “number” doesn’t even mean anything in math.

odyssey7yesterday at 10:34 PM

Hey, don’t blame me, blame the IAU for opening that can of worms. I’m just happy calling Pluto a “planet” and would rather the IAU had left me in peace — they’re the ones who want to argue with me about what words I’m supposed to say and when I’m supposed to say them.

I’d encourage you to think about the impact of science fiction on interest in science. Culture is an extremely powerful force. I don’t think your concern would bear out.

show 1 reply