logoalt Hacker News

Sir_Twistyesterday at 10:24 PM2 repliesview on HN

Would Chrome, Android, and YouTube be viable companies without the money-printing engine that is Google’s ad business? I’m for less consolidation in the tech industry, but I wonder whether a good balance could be struck between great services like these versus how they actually make money.


Replies

stuartdyesterday at 10:40 PM

The latter two potentially yes, as they can sell a product. Chrome - not so much: sell the browser, embed ads… nothing palatable.

show 1 reply
bogwogyesterday at 10:52 PM

> Would Chrome, Android, and YouTube be viable companies without the money-printing engine that is Google’s ad business?

Short answer? Yes. Long answer? Definitely.

> I wonder whether a good balance could be struck between great services like these versus how they actually make money.

I see you have an unconventional definition of the word "great". I'll take that to mean you're an outside-the-box thinker, so you're in a good position to understand that a break up of Google would radically change all the markets they're dominant in.

If Android 'dies' post-breakup, that would leave a gaping hole in the economy. iOS might fill it, but regulators would need to break them up too. Say iOS 'dies' too, would we all collectively just stop using smartphones? Obviously not. Entrepreneurs who can see opportunity will raise money and hire the right people to build a new OS, foundations will apply for grants to maintain Android or iOS forks, industry standards will form to improve interop and reduce development costs, etc. The sky's the limit!

show 2 replies