logoalt Hacker News

reconnectingyesterday at 7:18 AM2 repliesview on HN

By coincidence, we've been building software for five years that other plant managers are now considering using to keep track of some operational metrics. And I don't think we should put LLMs into our development cycle, simply because the data our software is built for can have critical meaning in some situations.

The insecurity in a vibe-coded web portal isn't that someone hacks it with XSS, it's that after the next vibe-coded release, some X quietly becomes −Y somewhere no one expects.

From this perspective, having no software at all might be better, or as in your case, safer.


Replies

Quothlingyesterday at 8:50 AM

I don't think you should keep AI away from software development for security reasons. We're in the European economic area and are completely NIS2 compliant and we use LLM's to aid in our software development for high risk systems. None of that is vibe coded though, so it's not like I disagree with you either.

As you point out this portal isn't that, but what protects us is the processes around compliance. This can't grow from X to Y because not even the CEO has the authority to overwrite our compliance gates. The EU is a tremendous help in this area since personal liability changed things completely.

show 2 replies
samuelknightyesterday at 11:36 AM

If you aren't using AI to write your code you should definitely be using it to find bugs in the code you write by hand.