logoalt Hacker News

toomuchtodoyesterday at 8:07 PM5 repliesview on HN

As someone else mentioned, ignore Ed’s personality and look solely at the balance sheets and capital analysis. Regardless of delivery, the math doesn’t math.

It's wild to me how much Ed is criticized while pathological liars like Musk and Altman are glossed over.

(Disclosure: I pay for Zitron's publication for the capital figures and exclusives he gets his hands on, I do not pay attention to his interviews, we are fact finding, if he wants to perform, I am not bothered, I've seen the performers on the other side, just keep the facts coming for ground truth)


Replies

sobellianyesterday at 11:33 PM

This was mentioned in the article.

> For example, when Timothy B. Lee looked at a spreadsheet that Zitron used to create a projection of Anthropic's revenue, he found, "He doesn't count February 1-10, counts March 1-10 twice, counts August 21-October 21 as one month instead of two, and doesn't count October 21-November 1. [another commenter notes that his spreadsheet also contains February 30] ... Ed claims he tried to compute Anthropic's revenue for 2025 and came up with $3.6 billion, suggesting some funny business [but the numbers work out once you fix the errors]"

tim333yesterday at 9:40 PM

As someone with a bit of understanding of accounts and finance I don't think Ed's analysis is very good. He's not someone who would pass a finance exam.

show 1 reply
jsLavaGoatyesterday at 8:29 PM

I posted here a while ago when his bubble prediction lapsed and plenty of his fans were here. Telling me how I was wrong and the Q2 reports weren't complete yet because it was still early July and blah blah

rowanG077yesterday at 8:10 PM

Are we living in the same universe? Musk and Altman are glossed over and not criticized?

show 2 replies
aleph_minus_oneyesterday at 8:09 PM

> while pathological liars like Musk and Altman are glossed over.

You seem to live in a bubble where these people are worshipped ... :-(

show 2 replies