logoalt Hacker News

MarkusWandelyesterday at 6:05 PM8 repliesview on HN

Being an "aging brain" myself I can totally relate to this. I've been a relatively obsessive photographer (i.e. visual diary) since digital cameras were practical, i.e. over 25 years now. 238K photos in the collection so far, and I can actually find things in it.

And I've more than once found that an anecdote I've been telling has been incorrect, precisely in a "melded memories" kind of way. It happened at this sort of gathering which were usually held for that reason so X was involved... and then finally look at the old pictures and there's no sign of X. It is literally the brain invoking "lossy compression" to make it all fit, just like certain web services that let you upload pictures without limit might reduce old ones, that hardly anyone ever looks at any more, to lower quality to limit storage bloat.

Of course any married man can confirm that this only applies to men. Women's memories are flawless. If they claim that they remember a conversation exactly, word for word, 20 years later, who's to prove them wrong?


Replies

mdavidnyesterday at 10:20 PM

Can confirm. This "aging brain" regularly and vividly inserts my child into memories created before they existed.

show 1 reply
someothherguyytoday at 12:05 AM

as you say, everyone does this. you just have the evidence and the humility to admit it.

nkrisctoday at 12:55 AM

Perhaps the rate of occurrence changes, but everybody does this at every age. When even our experience is an interpretation of the real world, our memories are even less accurate.

YesBoxyesterday at 7:04 PM

Just throwing out an idea: I recently stumbled upon an old-school website where someone is uploading a photo of their day (almost) every single day since 1998.

Came across screen captures of the original Everquest (SO COOL) and other games, photos of anime/cosplay events, city shots, family, friends, etc. Really fun for them, and fun for people who like me who still enjoy surfing the web.

edit: Screencap of an Everquest screencap for funsies: https://imgur.com/a/HUqc6p5

show 2 replies
mashygpigyesterday at 10:54 PM

I don’t think the sexist comment at the end is appropriate for HN

show 1 reply
boothbyyesterday at 9:13 PM

> Of course any married man can confirm that this only applies to men.

My first read of this headline was to observe that people seem to get more comfortable stereotyping people different from them as they age. Thanks for the datum.