logoalt Hacker News

kroatonyesterday at 8:44 PM8 repliesview on HN

I think it mostly shows that there is no moat and the only advantage the U.S companies have over the Chinese is more compute. Qwen Max, Kimi K3, GLM 5.3 are really close to Opus/Sol/Fable/Astra and they are open weights.


Replies

treefrytoday at 5:59 AM

From my experience with complex coding tasks (AI infra), I don't think these open weight models are close.

aurareturntoday at 2:39 AM

  I think it mostly shows that there is no moat
You can argue that TSMC has no moat since Intel and Samsung are also able to eventually make a node as good as TSMC - just a few years later and at smaller scale.

And no one would say that about TSMC.

So there is clearly a moat there somewhere.

show 2 replies
davidguettayesterday at 10:14 PM

bringing the price down b.c. competition != no moat.

There's not 100 frontier labs, it's not like airline companies

show 1 reply
Razenganyesterday at 11:09 PM

The "moat" is the "harness", the app.

For most people, the app IS the AI.

And even for its wonkiness, ChatGPT has had the best UX/UI of them all.

The way to win the AI wars in the eyes of the common folk is through the frontend, to be the Apple of AI, as it were.

show 1 reply
tonyhart7yesterday at 9:35 PM

they don't have moat in hardware either

Chinese counterpart like CXMT and Huawei is begin producing their own chip

You cant block an entire nation level effort with tariff

show 1 reply
VirusNewbieyesterday at 10:03 PM

If there was no moat, nvidia and meta would have SoTA models too.

show 3 replies
keeganpoppenyesterday at 10:33 PM

“there is no moat”, even though openai and anthropic both have paused development and are working off internal models that are like yet another revision ahead of what has even been released. and open source models only ever catch up to what is already publicly released because all they do is distill openai and antropic models. but yeah: “no moat”.

show 1 reply
m3kw9today at 2:18 AM

They have a lot of moat, i'm not sure what youa re talking about. Only amatures are using Qwen, open source stuff that is 3-8 weeks behind. Plus OpenAI has some verticals that keep people in there.

show 2 replies