logoalt Hacker News

jbrittonyesterday at 9:43 PM2 repliesview on HN

Watch a chess bot championship here: https://youtu.be/7g-jN3DTkWQ?is=HV3cdcICIRMbswQ3

Then realize LLMs have zero of what anyone would consider intelligence.


Replies

jbrittontoday at 1:27 AM

I decided to reply to my own comment. In the video above, the initial moves are textbook. Then a position that has never been played is reached. At this point it appears to pattern match against a similar but different board and pattern matches some follow on board. The result is illegal moves and no ability to see checks, captures, threats, tactics.

Which is strange because I’m sure it could give general advice about how to play better, it just doesn’t follow the rules it can enumerate. It also doesn’t seem to have spatial awareness.

I used to think LLMs couldn’t do Fibonacci for the same reason. They could write the code but not follow it. They can now follow a procedure to generate fib numbers but it seems to be memory limited.

So I don’t know why it can track fib algo, but no chess concepts.

show 1 reply