logoalt Hacker News

dataflowyesterday at 11:10 PM3 repliesview on HN

> This

As in, GPS being off by 33 feet?

> leads to people getting reincarcerated

I'm reading your article and it seems to be about police coming to check and realizing that the reporting of being miles away was in error, not people getting reincarcerted because of GPS incorrectly reporting they moved ~30 feet too far? One of these is much more insane than the other.


Replies

leptonstoday at 5:04 AM

>This

You're cherry-picking a single word to start a pointless internet argument? Calm down. Nobody claimed this exact event lead to problems for anyone.

This is what OP actually said:

>>This is exactly the sort of thing

Yes, this absolutely is the sort of thing. No, 33 feet isn't "the thing" but GPS glitching is the sort of thing at a different increment.

show 1 reply
iamshstoday at 12:13 AM

The story is about GPS errors which end up making life hell for people under monitoring since they end up generating a Police response. If 80% alerts were false, then an error like this can result in a surge of these alerts. It is an important story to tell.

show 1 reply
chapsyesterday at 11:38 PM

Not sure where your confusion is coming from. Have you never used GPS in a place with bad signal? Where it gets confused and you miss your turn? It's the same failure mode. Just the repercussions are getting arrested instead of getting off on the wrong exit.

Also wrote this one, hopefully it helps your confusion: https://chicagoreader.com/news/false-alarms/

show 3 replies