logoalt Hacker News

avazhitoday at 12:27 AM5 repliesview on HN

> so presumably a number of them are attached to people who did no crimes.

You and I have very divergent views of the type of person likely to be charged or prosecuted for a crime or indeed to participate in a diversion program that involves GPS trackers, my friend.


Replies

qltetoday at 2:57 AM

Your heuristic is flawed. The pool of defendants with pending charges who were granted pre-trial home detention are going to be disproportionately non-violent, first-time offenders compared to those denied bail or with prohibitively large amounts.

Meaning an error like this harms innocent people wrongly accused more than the stereotypically hardened repeat offenders you imagine to be undeserving of your sympathy and presumed guilty.

show 1 reply
ryandraketoday at 1:01 AM

Right, because only guilty people become involved with the justice system.

show 1 reply
crtifiedtoday at 1:25 AM

Not at all. They're remarkably similar. What differs is our cost:benefit analysis of closing off this errata.

Yours (inferred) is "Too Much : Zero".

Given that those are terminal values it would challenging for literally-any-other-view not to diverge from yours, on this.

show 1 reply
raframtoday at 1:59 AM

They are innocent until they’re proven guilty.

show 1 reply