logoalt Hacker News

wonnagetoday at 4:35 AM2 repliesview on HN

This article presents some evidence for why Grep might work better but I don’t think it does a great job of explaining why it gets chosen - is it something that was intentionally reinforced during training or was it just because LSP is harder to train on because it’s usually hidden behind some IDE interface

There’s no reason why you couldn’t write a search tool that e.g combines LSP and grep. Or ast-grep, for that matter. It feels like one of those things we haven’t spent much time investigating because grep is good enough


Replies

kaonashi-tyc-01today at 4:44 AM

"is it something that was intentionally reinforced during training or was it just because LSP is harder to train on because it’s usually hidden behind some IDE interface"

that's also my doubt, it's much easier to train with grep while only a fraction of project can setup LSP properly.

nullbiotoday at 5:27 AM

Training a model on ast-grep would be a huge intelligence and performance boost, I think.