logoalt Hacker News

dv_dttoday at 7:02 AM1 replyview on HN

A pull request is a communication to the project. AI or no AI, a poorly communicated request is a burden. IMHO AI prs are fine as long as the submitter has done the work to refine that communication to make it easy to read and assess.


Replies

LtWorftoday at 7:41 AM

True, the problem is that AI ones are 500x longer and at a first glance look fine, so they waste much more time.

Moreover a human contributor can learn and do better in the next PR, while the AI won't, unless the prompt is changed, but the operator won't learn.

show 1 reply