logoalt Hacker News

danielmarkbrucetoday at 3:10 AM4 repliesview on HN

You are conflating "half built" with "a piece of a system".

The model weights change as the model goes through the training process. They aren't stored after pre-training is done and other weights are put somewhere else. It's more like pottery - the thing changes. It's not correct to say something is soft and malleable because it once was.


Replies

dijksterhuistoday at 3:43 AM

> The model weights change as the model goes through the training process.

Yes. They do. You are absolutely right about that.

But the model architecture doesn't change as a result of the training process. A piston doesn't suddenly turn into a digital watch as a result of tuning an engine. Similarly, the transformer part of a GPT model doesn't suddenly turn into something else as a result of optimizing a loss function.

---

i've got other stuff to do, so i'm stopping here.

show 1 reply
Dylan16807today at 5:08 AM

You're using the fact the both parts of training affect the same weights to support your argument that they're making the system do something fundamentally different after RL?

show 1 reply