logoalt Hacker News

Dylan16807yesterday at 9:22 PM1 replyview on HN

What do you want it to use instead?

"I" is normally used for everything. You could be writing from the perspective of a slab of concrete and you'd use "I".


Replies

kdkdkwndjekdyesterday at 9:35 PM

I want it to use nothing. Use impersonal statements. Say “X was changed for Y” not “I changed X for Y”. As any tool would.

Finder doesn’t ask “Do you want ME to delete this file?”. Photoshop doesn’t ask “Do you want ME to save this file?”. Claude shouldn’t assume itself to be a person either.

> You could be writing from the perspective of a slab of concrete and you'd use "I".

Except this isn’t prose. Claude is not telling me a story from the point of view of a concrete slab. It is assuming personality to present objective facts. If my entire operating system can be interfaced with without it referring to itself as “I” then so can Claude.

show 3 replies