logoalt Hacker News

20kyesterday at 11:01 PM4 repliesview on HN

We're having to rediscover in real time the extremely hard way, why enabling mass theft is so incredibly damaging to society. This is literally why we need a functional copyright system

If theft becomes more profitable than genuine creation, then nobody will create anything. Then there's nothing to steal, at which point all progress collapses


Replies

paxystoday at 1:44 AM

What theft? LLM output has never been copyrightable.

show 1 reply
ralph84today at 1:55 AM

Nobody owns math and it is ridiculous to suggest someone should.

zer00eyztoday at 4:16 AM

> why enabling mass theft is so incredibly damaging to society. This is literally why we need a functional copyright system

What is interesting is that LLM's do not directly violate copyright. The settlements we have seen are for how the works were acquired (that was a copyright violation) not the use of the works.

The vectors of a book, or a paper, are not the paper. They are, for all intents, facts about the work itself, and more generally writing. You can not copyright a fact.

It also means that the weights, the things that (mostly) matter can not be copyrighted either.

CamperBob2yesterday at 11:49 PM

This is literally why we need a functional copyright system

To block progress. Got it.

show 1 reply