logoalt Hacker News

pvillanotoday at 2:08 AM2 repliesview on HN

The way to tame a profit-maximizer is to make the most profitable choice the one that creates the most societal good.

I would like to see the Clay Institute give zero recognition for formalizations without human-readable proofs. That would incentivize OpenAI to scram or create something that's actually useful.


Replies

jfrbfbreudhtoday at 2:14 AM

It would be trivially easy to convert Lean into English, so I’m not sure what the human-readable criteria gets you. There are also human written proofs that are considered not human-readable by most of the mathematics community (ABC conjecture).

show 1 reply
Jblx2today at 4:03 AM

OpenAI has already said they aren't going to claim the $1,000,000. If this proof claim holds up, then the Millennium prizes will be 2 for 2 for rejections of the prize money for valid solutions. Maybe that will be the precedent for other AI labs as well.