logoalt Hacker News

murderfstoday at 3:22 AM1 replyview on HN

> Somewhat functional in the trivial problem domains, and always useless where design choices mattered.

This is laughable when you consider that semiconductor design is the least "trivial" problem domain, and it happens entirely in RTL. There's basically zero human intervention when it comes to layout: even floorplanning is being automated nowadays.


Replies

Joel_Mckaytoday at 12:23 PM

Fab standard cell libraries are already the practical optimization of their current capabilities, and even FPGA try to minimize routing proximity with various levels of success. However, there are again named problems that constrain what naive people can get away with....

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Clock_domain_crossing

> floorplanning is being automated nowadays.

Procedural generation or parametric design is not the same, as the behavior and constraints were rationally engineered by people.

LLM would simply look at the outputs during training, abstract it as looking similar to a potato-chip factory, and generate a nonsense answer some fool assumes is appropriate.

Humans are wired to see meaningful patterns in chaotic systems even when they aren't really there. Neuromorphic computing may create real "AI" someday, but it almost certainly won't be from LLM cults. =3

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Pareidolia