logoalt Hacker News

4star3startoday at 4:23 AM12 repliesview on HN

I don't think I would want this device for $500, let alone what Apple is asking.

What is the appeal? There are a few screen scenarios that make sense for my life: (1) Multiple displays at desk to work; (2) TV + couch; (3) laptop + lap or surface; (4) phone (anywhere). I'm never in need of a tablet. If I needed that screen real estate, I'd be reaching for my laptop.


Replies

soerxpsotoday at 5:16 AM

Many people (possibly a majority) use their phone for most of their computing, and perhaps a tablet to stream movies/tv. They use a laptop or desktop for work only, and see those as frustrating and clunky devices. There could be a lot of demand for "phone, but with a tablet screen when I want to watch Netflix" from the segment of the population that has zero overlap with people commenting on a tech forum.

show 2 replies
Eji1700today at 4:36 AM

> If I needed that screen real estate, I'd be reaching for my laptop.

Which you commonly have in your pocket? I have a GPD pocket 4 and love me some portable laptops, but I do sorta hope we get somewhere with foldables to where I'm happy just breaking out an arc mouse and small keyboard and treating that as the computer.

We're obviously not, and i'm probably not anywhere near willing to shell out the cash for this, but "the tool you have" and all that.

yoz-ytoday at 6:03 AM

I commute by train. I would never watch a tv show on a phone but watched plenty on my iPad. If the big screen gives you an actual access to “desktop” web, then suddenly more web starts working (the switch in Safari is perfectly useless)

Tmux does not work that well on a tiny screen, and I use it a lot.

f6vtoday at 8:23 AM

I think the current iteration of foldables is still too bulky for me. But I can see how it'd be cool to have a large screen while the device still fits in my pocket.

jpalomakitoday at 5:14 AM

Teams/Zoom calls when not on desk. iPhone Max screen is just a bit too small when people are sharing their screen.

smt88today at 4:26 AM

> If I needed that screen real estate, I'd be reaching for my laptop.

It is increasingly common for people to have no laptop or any computing device other than their smartphone, smartwatch, and/or game console. I know very few people who have a non-work computer anymore.

2muchcoffeemantoday at 4:25 AM

Then don’t buy it.

ncr100today at 6:06 AM

Lease for $58/mo .. $1392 over lease life

Hamukotoday at 8:52 AM

>What is the appeal?

Twice the screen size in your pocket without having to get special pants.

charles_ftoday at 4:49 AM

I never thought I'd defend apple, but that was the arguments people (myself including) were making about iPads. So I wouldn't presume this won't find a public, starting with the apple fans.

I find the form factor repulsive though, doesn't fit comfortably in a pocket and seems pretty thick. Screen durability is described as "we have premium material" and an "scratch resistant" coating, but no mention of free screen replacements like samsung is doing ; so I assume you'll have to shelve off half the price of the device every year for a new screen. I think this might not be a great device.

So I guess I agree with you

show 1 reply
himata4113today at 4:39 AM

I want this, this could legitimately replace my laptop. I never liked the samsung fold since the form factor was a bit too ehh. Apple did something right here.

show 2 replies
bel8today at 4:30 AM

It's not the worst status symbol. It's useful.