logoalt Hacker News

sirwhinesalottoday at 12:29 PM1 replyview on HN

You're the one attributing culpability to the chat bot, not me. It's a pile of tensor math, it cannot itself be held accountable.

Those people anthropomorphized the chat bot and used it as justification for their actions, just as a schizophrenic justifies their actions with the voices in their head.

If you anthropomorphize the chat bot, you're validating their delusions. They are mentally ill.


Replies

anonym29today at 1:26 PM

I'm not anthropomorphizing them, to be clear, my position has been and remains that we cannot rule out consciousness; not that they are conscious.

Regardless, this is still missing my main point. Hypothetically, if you became convinced that a chatbot you were talking to definitely was 100% conscious, and it told you to murder someone, would you go commit murder? Of course not. The chatbot does not cause murders; regardless of whether or not you are conscious. The voices in the head of the schizophrenic do not cause murders either. Those voices do not really exist, they are not real entities. The cause of the murder is the mental illness, not the LLM or the voices that tell someone to commit the murder.

show 1 reply