logoalt Hacker News

zanellato19yesterday at 8:01 PM2 repliesview on HN

i.e., luck


Replies

cheesecakegoodtoday at 12:52 AM

If luck = something you didn’t choose or had no control over, sure.

If luck = it could have gone otherwise, that’s nonsensical; if you had different parents you wouldn’t exist to begin with, as you are literally a specific fusion of your biological parents. Similarly, if we take luck to mean something probabilistic, or something coincidental? Also meaningless in this case.

If luck = how your situation compares to others, I would argue “fortunate” is the better word here.

And of course there’s a parallel spiritual debate if you believe that identity to be separate (were you “assigned” to parents, was it deliberate or random, etc)

eikenberryyesterday at 8:47 PM

And 2 is lucky it is the sum of 1+1.